Baldur’s Gate 3: Should you give your eye to Auntie Ethel?

Baldur’s Gate 3 is a game rife with difficult choices, including when Auntie Ethel offers to ‘kiss’ your eye to rid you of the Mindflayer parasite. Are you confused about accepting or declining? This guide gives you the best choice and what it entails.

Auntie Ethel regularly appears in the game, often at the least expected times, throwing a wrench in your plans with her questionable actions.

One such time is when she offers to help your Mindflayer parasite problem, by offering to “kiss” your eye and remove the ailment. So, should you accept or is that possibly the worst mistake your character can make? Let’s take a look and find out.

Read with caution, there are a few minor spoilers below.

Should you allow Auntie Ethel to ‘kiss’ your eye in Baldur’s Gate 3?

No, you shouldn’t allow Auntie Ethel to ‘kiss’ your eye in Baldur’s Gate 3. This old woman is a hag (a creature with big hands and gigantic claws, very similar to a witch), and not someone as sweet as she appears to be. Things will go completely wrong if you allow her to take your eye.

You might be tempted to give your eye for the cure. However, upon doing that, you’ll receive “Paid the Price”, a permanent debuff for the rest of the game. This will put you in a disadvantageous position as you won’t be able to land critical hits anymore.

More so, it becomes worse as Ethel stops in the middle of the process. What you’re left with is a damaged green eye, permanent debuff, and the parasite still in the brain. We recommend not to fall for this deal, instead, search her hut as you get something valuable in return.

You’ll come across this old woman arguing with two brothers while passing by a tea house around the southern areas of the map.

So, there you have it — that’s everything you need to know about Auntie Ethel’s eye choice in Baldur’s Gate 3. For more about Baldur’s Gate 3, be sure to check our other content and guides:

Best Sorcerer build | Best Bard build | Best Rogue build | Best Fighter build | Best Ranger build | Best Barbarian build | Best Druid build | Best Warlock build | Best Wizard build | Baldur’s Gate 3: What’s the max level cap? | Best Baldur’s Gate 3 classes tier list | How to revive characters in Baldur’s Gate 3 | Can you multiclass in Baldur’s Gate 3 | Baldur’s Gate 3 Soul Coins: How to get them & what they are