American Horror Story: All seasons ranked worst to best

Jasmine Valentine
Jessica Lange in American Horror StoryFX

The signature Ryan Murphy creation American Horror Story has stuck around for the long haul – even when fans thought that it shouldn’t.

The horror anthology has now been on our screens for over a decade, bringing viewers a different storyline with a brand-new set of actors every season since 2011.

While some of them live on forever in the form of memes and YouTube clips, other seasons have been left by the wayside or completely forgotten altogether.

Article continues after ad

With Season 12, titled American Horror Story: Delicate, airing now, we won’t be including it until after its finale. In the meantime, here’s every season of American Horror Story ranked from worst to best.

11. American Horror Story: Double Feature (Season 10)

Lily Rabe and Macaulay Culkin in AHD Double Feature.FX

When it comes to which season fans dislike the most, it almost unanimously comes back to American Horror Story: Double Feature.

Staying true to its name, the tenth season aired in two halves, following the “pale people” Red Tide storyline in Part 1 before jumping to the alien conspiracy Death Valley in Part 2. It doesn’t initially look like the two have anything to do with each other, and hardened fans of the show might agree that both sides never match up.

Article continues after ad

Not only is it all really confusing, but the decision to make two halves into a whole feels like a last-ditch attempt to bring the AHS glory days back. Some fans hinge the epic fail on the second half in particular, disappointed in the lack of explanation and ropey plot.

10. American Horror Story: Apocalypse (Season 8)

The Witches Coven in AHS ApocalypseFX

Season 8 was the moment American Horror Story looked to redeem itself after a few rocky seasons, bringing back stalwarts like Jessica Lange, and including new cast members such as Joan Collins.

Article continues after ad

Murphy also finally made good on his promise to somehow revive Coven in the same year, with Apocalypse featuring a brief cross-over with characters from Season 3. It’s dark, it’s camp, and best of all, Cordelia Goode is still convinced that she’s the Supreme.

Even so, fans haven’t been able to get past the half-baked ending Apocalypse had, suggesting that the events throughout the season were essentially a dream. Not only do some viewers feel that the season was badly written, but such a big promise ends up failing to go anywhere.

Article continues after ad

9. American Horror Story: Cult (Season 7)

Evan Peters in AHS CultFX

American Horror Story is widely known for being scary, but the season that got too close for comfort was certainly Cult.

Following the election of President Trump in 2016, franchise favorites Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters spearhead a story exploring the fallout for a local restaurant owner and a misogynistic alt-righter. The results include a few public standoffs that few would dare to be involved with, also commenting on the impact of gun culture in the country.

Article continues after ad

It’s another different style for AHS, but it’s also the first season that really feels the effects of missing core actors. Jessica Lange is now long gone, with season regulars such as Kathy Bates and Angela Bassett no longer putting in appearances. Paulson and Peters are doing the heavy lifting here, and it shows.

8. American Horror Story: NYC (Season 11)

Zachary Quinto in AHS NYCFX

After the disaster that was American Horror Story: Double Feature, NYC looked like a saving grace.

The season follows a series of murders targeting the LGBT+ community in New York City, spurning a newfound hatred for the NYPD. Not only does this season feel timely, but it has a distinctively different style to any AHS season that has come before.

Article continues after ad

With a new look comes mixed feelings, leaving viewers divided on whether they like the direction that the franchise has taken. It’s not necessarily that anything is wrong with NYC – more that it doesn’t hold up to the excellence of previous seasons, with some fans saying they’ve still never heard of it.

7. American Horror Story: Roanoke (Season 6)

Kathy Bates in AHS Roanoke.FX

One of the only seasons of AHS to directly tackle a true story, Roanoke probably wins the award for the scariest season in the franchise.

Article continues after ad

Looking at the supernatural events that took place in a farmhouse in North Carolina, most of the action is made up of jumpscares, sordid history, and a Colony that once mysteriously went missing. What’s more surprising is the time jump halfway through the season, revealing that everything fans had previously seen was the set-up for a fictional documentary.

Roanoke is a little rough around the edges, but when it needs to scare, it delivers the goods. Fans praised the season for its unique take on what it has tried to do before, while others feel Season 6 gets hated on for little reason.

Article continues after ad

6. American Horror Story: Hotel (Season 5)

Kathy Bates and Denis O'Hare in AHS HotelFX

Another series to divided opinion, American Horror Story: Hotel was a watch that fans either loved or hated.

As the first season since the departure of Jessica Lange, it was up to Lady Gaga to pick up the slack as the vampiric Countess. It’s the first time we get to see her acting chops and she doesn’t disappoint, making a particularly memorable scene involving blood, a circular bed, and many random lovers.

Sarah Paulson is also on hand to do some stellar work as heroin junkie Sally, while regulars such as Kathy Bates fade more into the background. The only possible downside is the season’s scope – other than the hotel itself, what really is there?

Article continues after ad

5. American Horror Story: 1984 (Season 9)

The summer camp gang in AHS 1984FX

The surprise comeback of the franchise came with American Horror Story: 1984, with previous regulars such as Emma Roberts returning for a slasher-style comedy.

Taking the classic cabin-in-the-woods type of horror and running with it, the cast is stuck at a newly reopened summer camp, trying to survive a dangerous killer on the loose. It’s a tried and tested format and one that worked well for the return of another AHS season.

Fans credit 1984 for its strong writing, as well as the unexpected humor found throughout the season. After her role in Murphy’s Scream Queens, it’s no surprise that Roberts excels in the role of camp newbie Brooke. The intro of Season 9 is also seen as a definite fan favorite.

Article continues after ad

4. American Horror Story: Freak Show (Season 4)

Pepper in AHS Freak ShowFX

Saying goodbye to Jessia Lange was never going to be an easy task, but Freak Show made sure it delivered – mostly by getting her to sing Lana Del Rey in the 1950s.

That detail doesn’t really make much sense, but it doesn’t need to. Riding on the coattails of something we already find fascinating, AHS followed a struggling freak show in Jupiter, Florida, and two newcomers who find it and begin to cause trouble.

Article continues after ad

Freak Show isn’t a perfect AHS season, but it packs enough punch to stick out in the ranks of the best ever. Lange commands the screen as show leader Elsa, while Sarah Paulson proves why she’s worth her weight in gold by playing two conjoined characters at once. Bonus points for Patti LaBelle randomly dressing up as Woody Woodpecker.

3. American Horror Story: Murder House (Season 1)

Evan Peters in AHS Murder HouseFX

Sometimes, you can’t beat where it all began – and Murder House is a season of American Horror Story that’s still quoted and memed to this day.

Article continues after ad

Following a family who move into an old house, they soon learn that their home sweet home has some horrid history, alongside some overly familiar faces who can’t seem to stay away.

It’s the first and only time we see stars such as Connie Britton and Kate Mara appear in the franchise, leaving us wanting more from their standoffish drama – including a stranger in a full latex suit. Fans like that Murder House is the most horror-oriented season of the bunch, alongside packing in some incredibly hard-hitting twists.

Article continues after ad

2. American Horror Story: Coven (Season 3)

Taissa Farmiga and Evan Peters in AHS CovenFX

If there is an excerpt of AHS to be seen, it’s probably come from Coven. Timed with when the franchise started to gain popularity across the globe, the season marks everything American Horror Story does as its best.

A mix of moody, dark, historically accurate, and humorous, Coven follows a group of witches who aim to find their new Supreme, while tensions with the New Orleans voodoo community look to cause trouble. Jessica Lange’s Fiona remains untouchable throughout, while Emma Roberts’ Madison Montgomery delivers burns that most of us could only dream of.

Article continues after ad

With characters as strong as these, it’s no surprise that fans wanted more of them as the franchise continued. For fans, the thread of witchcraft is what holds it together, able to be both entertaining and intriguing at the same time.

1. American Horror Story: Asylum (Season 2)

A scene from AHS AsylumFX

In the history of American Horror Story seasons, Asylum was the one that had it all.

Looking at a church-owned mental asylum was never going to be a bad idea, but AHS doubled down on the intrigue by offering strong storylines played out by an exceptional group of actors. The series is the first to include musical numbers, alongside definitive time jumps between the present and the future.

Article continues after ad
Comment
byu/markstormweather from discussion
inhorror

If nothing else, Asylum showed that it had ambition – and every risk it took seemed to pay off. From possessed nuns to mad scientists and alien encounters, this season had it all while managing to keep all of its plates spinning. Time for a verse of Name Game, anyone?

You can check out everything we know about American Horror Story Season 12 here and check out our other coverage below:

About The Author

Jasmine Valentine is a TV and Movies Writer at Dexerto. She's written for the likes of Total Film, The Daily Beast, and Radio Times. Jasmine loves anime, dystopian thrillers, and anything starring Tilda Swinton. You can email her here: jasmine.waters@dexerto.com.