NYXL under fire for reportedly building OWL roster of “marginalized genders”

The Overwatch League’s New York Excelsior is facing backlash after reports claimed the team was looking to build a roster consisting of “marginalized genders.”

On November 28, reports emerged that the NYXL was reaching out to players of “marginalized genders” to be part of the team’s squad for 2023. However, this is something that has people part of that community concerned.

Check out the best Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals on Amazon

According to OWL insider Arran Spake, the NYXL’s owners have been pushing for the team to go in this direction, but players who have been approached don’t want to join, because they don’t want “handouts.”

News of the roster change has many fans and players worried, saying there isn’t enough talent to pool from marginalized groups to form a roster capable of competing at the highest level.

Also on NYXL, as I understand it. The decision has come from the owners and they have pushed it.

This wasn’t a GM decision https://t.co/zcmGXq1lpS

— Arran Spake (@haloofthoughts) November 28, 2022

Overwatch 2 players slam NYXL for marginalized gender roster

The backlash to the reports came quickly with many aspiring pros taking issue with the OWL team’s decision.

“I want to join an OWL team based on skill and not because of my gender, the fact that NYXL is wanting to make an all marginalized gender team that they know will struggle is frustrating,” remarked Aspen – a female support main.

I want to join an OWL team based on skill and not because of my gender, the fact that NYXL is wanting to make an all marginalized gender team that they know will struggle is frustrating. Put resources into Calling all Heroes or OD/Contenders if you truly want to help

— GUARD Aspen (@Aspen_OW) November 28, 2022

London Spitfire GM Ysabel ‘Noukky’ Müller called the roster a “really bad idea.”

“There is simply not enough talent yet to be a serious competitor or development team,” she said, recommending the team invest in Calling All Heroes instead.

Talked about this privately a lot with people after hearing about it and this thread sums up most of my thoughts on it.
Its a REALLY bad idea. There is simply not enough talent yet to be a serious competitor or development team. Better invest in a CAH team instead. https://t.co/oTzcfoGIQb

— C9 Izzy (@Noukky) November 28, 2022

Calling All Heroes is a program Blizzard set up exclusive for certain genders to compete in, though it’s not on the same level as Contenders, Overwatch’s secondary esports competition.

Boston Uprising’s social media manager also panned the roster concept, further remarking how “there are few, if any, OWL-level players who are also a marginalized gender.”

1.) There are few, if any, OWL-level players who are also a marginalized gender.

This means that in terms of actual competition, the roster will struggle, and struggle DEARLY- think season 1 Shanghai Dragons.

This does a multitude of things, including confirming biases that-

— Aramori (@Aramori_OW) November 28, 2022

With all this backlash, it will be interesting to see if NYXL go ahead with the roster or backtrack and opt for a more traditional team.

If you click on a product link on this page we may earn a small affiliate commission.