Former Joe Rogan Podcast guest reportedly shot and dismembered a man

Meera Jacka
Former Joe Rogan Podcast guest reportedly dismembered and shot a man

A recent guest on the Joe Rogan Experience Podcast has been charged with murder after being caught with a dismembered corpse in a Bronx apartment.

A high-profile anti-violence activist and ex-con has been charged with murder, manslaughter, and weapon possession less than one month after appearing on The Joe Rogan Experience.

48-year-old Sheldon Johnson Jr. was taken in for questioning by police after reports of gunfire led officers to a Bronx apartment where the mutilated corpse of Colin Small was found.

Small had been dismembered, his decapitated head found with a bullet wound. Several body parts were also discovered inside a freezer, including Small’s severed arms, legs, and a foot.

Security footage showed a suspect assumed to be Johnson Jr. wearing various disguises as he entered and exited the building’s elevator. Nonetheless, Johnson Jr. declared his innocence to reporters as he was led from the 44th Precinct stationhouse to appear in Bronx Criminal Court.

Prior to his latest arrest, Johnson Jr. was sentenced to 50 years in an upstate prison for a 1997 robbery committed in his early 20s. He was released in May after 25 years and hired as a client advocate for Queens Defender.

Appearing on Joe Rogan’s podcast in an episode titled “Sentenced to 50 Years Sheldon Johnson Decided to Turn His Life Around,” Johnson Jr. discussed his criminal past and moving forward. His lawyer also appeared on the episode, dubbing Johnson Jr. a “miracle” and claiming he had been unfairly sentenced for the robbery.

Still available on YouTube, viewers pointed out how the episode failed to age well with Johnson Jr. arrested again for a much more serious crime this time.

“25 years locked up. Shouldn’t have been let out in the first place. I saw [an] article that stated it stemmed from a feud from his time in prison,” one person wrote, claiming Johnson Jr. “hasn’t changed one bit.”

“It’s a huge blow for criminal justice reform because folks will say he seemed fine and improved. Yet for this to happen how can we trust others,” another lamented. “Sad day for future people trying to better themselves because of this person’s actions assuming he’s convicted.”

About The Author

Meera Jacka is a Senior Entertainment and Trending News Writer on the Australian Dexerto team. She completed her undergrad at Curtin University with a double major in professional writing and publishing and creative writing, graduating with Honours in creative writing. A horror fan with a guilty pleasure in reality TV, Meera covers all things entertainment and trending news, with the occasional film and gaming content thrown in the mix. Contact Meera at meera.jacka@dexerto.com